DM.41/23
The Committee considered the
details of the planning applications prepared by the relevant Case
Officers as presented in the agenda papers, and considered the
comments of Town and Parish Councils, together with other
representations received, which were listed within the presented
agenda reports, and RESOLVED that:
6a) 1505/23/FUL Land At SX 654
517, New Mills Industrial
Estate, Modbury
This application was withdrawn.
6b) 1668/23/VARThe Mooring, Newton Hill, Newton Ferrers, PL8 1BG
Development: Variation of
Condition 1 (approved plans) of planning
consent0068/20/VAR
Case Officer
Update: The Case Officer summarised the
key issues, namely that:
•
Whether the proposed changes affect the external appearance of the
completed development.
•
Whether the changes give rise to loss of amenity for
neighbours
The Case Officer raised that
the previous objection to the fence was now accepted by the
neighbour and clarified the process for planning applications and
the rules around planning enforcement.
They also explained that the condition requires the applicant to
construct within the approved plans but can amend that condition
for screening to be a 1.8 metre height if required.
Having heard from speakers on
behalf of the Parish Council together with the Ward Councillor,
Members debated the application. During
the debate, one Member was happy to go with the officer
recommendation because of the agreed compromise between the
applicant and the objector. Another
Member was frustrated by the process because they were unaware
whether the applicant would be happy with the
proposals.
Recommendation:
Conditional Grant
Committee decision:
Delegated approval to the Head of Development Management subject to
alterations to the screening to be agreed with Chairman, Ward
Members, Proposer (Cllr Rake) and Seconder (Cllr Nix).
Conditions:
Adherence with approved plans.
Adherence with approved CMP.
Privacy screens to be installed prior to use of balcony.
Landscaping.
Timber to undercroft door North western
boundary wall to be clad in natural stone (5 months).
Wall on south eastern elevation to be
clad in stone.
6c) 3161/23/FUL Linhay Barn, Budlake,
Ermington, PL21 9NG
Development: Construction of a
new replacement dwelling to replace proposed barn conversion under
2767/17/FUL
The Case Officer provided an
update since the agenda was published and reported that following
discussions with the agents and architects the JLP Officer has made
some comments regarding the climate emergency and has highlighted
some inconsistencies.
Case Officer
Update: The Case Officer summarised the
key issues, namely that:
Policy
•
Within countryside location but does not meet criteria of
TTV26.
•
Not a replacement dwelling.
•
Contribution to housing supply does not justify
location.
•
Contrary to pattern of development.
•
Insufficient information to show that the proposal would conserve
and enhance rural landscape.
Other Matters
•
Barn Conversion
- Doubt whether
permission would still extant.
- Effectiveness of Legal Agreement.
- Securing long term further of barn.
- Comparison of carbon calculations for both proposals were
uncomplete.
•
Approved agricultural building:
- Cannot prevent
future prior approval applications.
Conclusion
•
Unsuitable location without appropriate planning justification for
countryside location.
•
...
view the full minutes text for item DM.41/23